Misconduct in the Church

Recently, I received a sad letter informing of a situation in a UK fellowship involving two people in leadership.

Such a letter, a necessary letter, to the church family, does not begin to express the sadness and pain that those involved are going through, and of course the repercussions of this situation extends to whole church family gathered there.

I would imagine, in response to this situation, that there will be some voices in the fellowship calling for some kind of … punishment, retribution, chastisement, ‘an example to be made’ especially as they were in leadership positions.    

Indeed, I think that there will be people who do not know, as believers, how they are to respond to this kind of situation.

Some, may feel or fear that they, too, could stumble in a like manner – which will affect their response.

There may be others who will call for an example to made of them because of their positions and influence, especially with the young people of the fellowship.

I dare say that those who espouse various and diverse responses and suggestions for the appropriate ‘church’ response to the ‘two’, that they would never identify that which they declare and which they would identify as the ‘appropriate response’, in such stark and draconian terms as ‘punishment’ or ‘retribution’ or ‘chastisement’ or ‘justice’ … nevertheless… there is more than a soupçon of these elements in that which is often clamoured for.

For myself and without sounding namby-pamby, or ‘soft on the Holiness of God’, or compromising, or being wishy-washy, and without wanting even the slightest detraction from the true awesomeness of the Holiness of God, the Righteousness of God, the High Standard we are called to as adopted sons and daughters of God, I must declare that I am very aware that we, sinners all, have been reconciled to God, by God, whilst in our bruised, smelly, imperfect, stained, failing and frail state…

Whilst we were and are, weak in the flesh, He has expressed His Grace – that is, the un-earned, un-merited favour of Almighty God, with abundant unearned, undeserved blessing, and the gift of true, eternal, Life in Christ to us, solely due to His Love, His Mercy and His Grace.

At no time and in no way do we condone sin, nor do we not turn a blind eye to the faults and failings in the Church, nor do we sit, silently, seeing no evil, speaking no evil, hearing no evil.

The love and compassion of God motivates us to speak – but in love.

Indeed, His Love demands that we challenge and and where necessary, reprimand – all the while knowing that we ourselves are weak and prone to fail. (James 5:19-20; Jude 1:22-23)

God’s unfailing Love calls us to challenge – first ourselves, and then our brothers and sisters, to live righteous, holy, true and pure lives. … provoking one another to love and good deeds … (Hebrews 10:24 KJV)

Scripture says that ‘love covers a multitude of sins’. (1 Peter 4:8)

This is not a licence to live recklessly.

This is not a ‘free pass’ to do whatever our old nature desires. Never! (Romans 6:15)

Our sins have been dealt with in Christ, on the Cross.

And more personally, my sins have been dealt with in Christ, on the Cross.

We are called to maintaining righteousness, holiness, the high moral standard that we are called to, and at the self same time, to be balanced with the Mercy, Love and the Grace (undeserved favour) of God.

This is not a binary choice; it is not one or the other; it is both.

Let me reiterate that: it is not a binary choice; it is not one or the other; it is both.

We do not have a ‘free pass’ to live as we used to when we were ignorant; nor do we emphasis the Grace of God and the Love of God to the exclusion of all else. (1 Corinthians 11:27-31)

At the opposite extreme, nor do we establish a new ‘law’ with clear, strict consequences for any divergence from the High Calling we are called to in Christ, diligently enforcing it for ‘His testimonies sake’ or for the ‘Holiness of God’ or for any other ‘right sounding’ reason.

We, fallen, redeemed, learning, struggling, sinners, saved-by-grace individuals that we are, have been brought into a living relationship with the Father; Almighty, Sovereign, God Himself. That is a relationship between each individual, individually, with Almighty Father God. At the same time, He has established and built us together into the Body of Christ; corporately, we are responsible for one another, loving one another, caring for one another, serving one another, forgiving one another, laughing with one another and yes, weeping with one another.

God the Father, the One who sacrificed His one and only Son that I might live, He is fully aware of all my sins, failings, poor choices, pettiness, anger, selfishness, self-righteousness, lust, jealousy… indeed everything. His awareness and knowledge is complete and more, far more than I am aware of my own faults and failings in my life. Truly, I am blissfully ignorant of the vast majority of my failings and sins… He, graciously, reveals the next thing He wants to change in my life, one or two at a time… thankfully…

Hence, I can consider myself only better than the two referenced in the letter if I take myself as my reference point.

But, if for a just a fraction of a second, I consider them and their failings and myself and my failings from God’s perspective, then, there is nothing for me to say, there is nothing I can say…

Nothing!

After reading the letter, my heart went out to the elders and leaders in the fellowship.

Confronting, discussing, seeking the Mind of Christ in all these things, affirming the positive steps the ‘two’ have taken in repentance, labouring to ensure that past failings remain in the past… corrective measures to ensure it does not occur again, concern for the rest of the fellowship, discerning what needs to be done, and what need to be left undone, what needs to be communicated to all… this is not easy. And all the while, knowing that they, as elders and leaders in the fellowship, are held accountable to God for their actions, decisions and the execution of their responsibilities to the fellowship.

Thankfully, the Head of the Church, the Lord Jesus Christ, bore the sins of the ‘two’, their transgressions, their bad choices, their actions; He – the Lord Jesus Christ – fully paid the price on the Cross, He bore it all. Indeed, even for these latest transgressions that they have committed as redeemed believers…

Yes, they have added to the pain and the suffering that Christ endured in His torment, His suffering, His total rejection, His death – but He willingly bore it to redeem them.

Let me hasten to add that I, too, as a believer, have knowingly, willingly added to the burdens that Christ, the sinless Son of God experienced on the cross; He willingly suffered, bore all my and our sins, was abandoned by the Father, to redeem each of us and set us (all) free from the bondage to our old natures with its desires and passions and habits.

As Jesus said, “Let him without sin cast the first stone”. (John 8:7 NIVUK)

And as Jesus further said “Go and sin no more”. (John 8:11 NIVUK)

Jesus also declared: “Do not judge, or you too will be judged.” (Matthew 7:1. NIVUK)

I can not begin to express the grief I feel – two individuals, very much in the public eye, very visible to the whole body of believers, and yet, no different from any of the rest of us, who slowly, slowly, drifted down a path that lead to such a painful and regrettable outcome.

I believe that the over-all lesson is that God is the Great God of Grace – He saved us when we were in total rebellion against Him and going our own proud and independent way; and that Grace is still flowing and still working in us to bring us to ‘perfection’.

We are not ‘perfect’ yet – dare I say, not even close.

But it is the Grace of God, at work in us, bringing us to true, heartfelt repentance, to bring us to maturity and to establish us in the Faith.

If any ‘righteous person’ disputes and feels that the ‘two’ need open and strict punishment (let the reader understand: harsh), please refer to Psalm 51 – the psalm of David after his sins, his lust, his adultery, his subterfuge, his conspiracy, ultimately having Urriah killed, his hypocrisy, and his willingness

 to ‘put it in the past’ and ‘forget about it’ – until God, though the prophet Nathan brought it out into the open. (2 Samuel chapters 11 & 12)

We have the definitive definition of what real ‘repentance’ is, from his life and his experience.

Of course, it would have far better for all if he had not sinned – but he did, and he suffered for his transgressions but not at the hand of a human judge, but as God Himself determined.

The final question, the most important question is not what ‘punishment’ is appropriate, or what sanctions musts needs be levelled against them nor even querying if the ‘two’ truly, honestly, have repented… for that is ultimately between them and God… but the final, essential question really is:

“Have ‘I’ truly repented of my own errors, poor choices, transgressions, sins…?”

The ‘two’ will stand, independently, before God and give an account of their actions, their choices and yes, their repentance.

As will I, for my actions, my choices and the truth of my ‘repentance’ from those areas of sin and weakness in my life.

As will you…

This sad event has transpired.

I believe that the essential focal point in consequence to these, now publicly confessed sins, is to marvel at the incredible, matchless Grace of God… who saves sinners such as us…

Indeed, if I need to progress beyond this, let me begin by “examining myself” to ensure that I have truly and honestly repented of the vast range of errors, poor choices, habits, and yes, ‘sins’ in my own life…